Highway to Hell: How Road Infrastructure Traps Us in an Unsustainable Nightmare (Episode 58 of Crazy Town) - Resilience

2022-06-10 23:16:57 By : Ms. Aries Tao

Don’t you wish we could power daily life on road rage, frustration, and righteous indignation? If that were possible, the U.S. highway system would be the best investment of all time. As it stands, the unintended consequences (e.g., pollution, habitat fragmentation, discrimination, town wrecking, dependency on unsustainable infrastructure, and the uglification of America) reveal how badly highways miss the mark. What a stupendous misallocation of resources! Fortunately we have some ideas about how to get from point A to point B and provision ourselves without relying on 18-wheelers and endless miles of asphalt. So get your motor runnin’ and head out on the highway for an adventure in transforming the transportation system. For episode notes and more information, please visit our website.

And I’m Jason Bradford. Welcome to Crazy Town where potholes are filled with the E-waste from outdated crypto farms.

This is producer Melody Travers, in this season of Crazy Town, Jason, Asher, and Rob are exploring the watershed moments in history that have led humanity into the cascading crises we face in the 21st century. Today’s episode is about paving the world with highways and getting locked into a transportation system that has way too many side effects. The watershed moment took place in 1919. At the time, the estimated carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere was 303 parts per million, and the global human population was 1.88 billion.

Hey, I know you guys are kind of old like me. You’re not as old as me. But can you remember far enough back in time to when you got your driver’s license? And what that felt like what you did?

In Atlanta? Yeah, of course. That opened up the city for exploration. Yeah, hey, I was now able to actually do something other than watch 80’s movies and reruns.

Yeah, living vicariously through my oldest who’s turning 16. And he’s driving us around and he’s about to get his license. I remember getting my license and feeling that freedom.

I do. I remember, there’s a place called Skyline Boulevard in the Bay Area, which runs literally on the Ridge of the Santa Cruz Mountains. Yeah. And I used to take my 1978 Volkswagen Rabbit on those roads, and I would just go away for a couple hours and nobody knew where I was, what I was doing.

Yeah, we would do that too. Like, my friend said, “Hey, let’s go to Alabama.” And so we did. And, of course, we ended up at an outlet shopping mall.

It was so worth it.

Yeah, yeah. So there’s that incredible sense freedom and adventure and power and all that. And songs come to mind that represent those feelings?

Oh, of course. I mean, what’s a road trip without some tunes? And since I was just thinking 80’s, one of my favorite road tripping songs back then was of course, “Life is a Highway” by the great Tom Cochran. And you would almost say that’s a one hit wonder. Except that it got re-recorded for the “Cars” movie by Pixar and became a mega hit.

It was his one hit.

Yeah, never heard of the guy.

Yeah, I still don’t even know who the hell you’re talking about.

But great song. Great. What a riff. This is one of Curtis, my son’s, favorites.

Oh, yeah. He’s kind of into country music.

We should have Curtis come in and sing it for us.

Yeah. What about you, Asher? Any songs come to mind?

Oh, that’s a good one. ACDC, baby. Ah, ah, what a riff.

I’m gonna take some heat for this. . . Why did that band ever become so popular?

What are you talking about? I mean, come on.

I don’t know. The screamy voice never did it for me.

What about the short shorts guy?

Oh, the guy who wore the Catholic school uniform while he jumps around on stage and plays guitar?

Yeah. Well, for me when I think about these songs, I think about Bruce Springsteen. He had a ton of songs that were about the road and the freedom and getting out of town “Darkness on the Edge of Town” and the river where they drive down to the river and “Born to Run” and I mean, just “Thunder Road.”

I mean, if you look at Americana music of all kinds, the road plays a prominent role in Dylan, you know, blues. I mean, think about it, right? Going down to the crossroads?

I know. Escape and sometimes carelessness. And the idea that you’re young and free. And you have these places you can get to second chances, you know. Pick it up from one place, go to another

Oh, it’s utterly built into the culture. I mean, you can go to the movies, too. And think of road trip movies and…

Drive-ins! Those were good. I remember those.

Yeah, yeah. Well, there’s a little dark side to that though, too, right. We’ve locked ourselves a little bit into something there. With our love affair with the road.

I know there’s this splendor we have this, these feelings that we have these teenage feelings we have. But yeah, I want to bring us into our watershed moment for this show, which is how did we build this road system? Where did this come from? And not just any road system, but the key road system that we want to talk about is this interstate highway system, the big freeways. And those didn’t just spring out of nowhere. There were people involved, there were ideas, there was inspiration. And let’s go back to the summer of 1919.

Oh, that was a good year.

I thought you were gonna go back to summer 1969.

Bryan Adams. When he got his first real six string and played it till his fingers bled.

Have you guys ever visited covered bridges?

Well yeah. It’s kind of a thing in Oregon. These cool little covered bridges -There’s one on the bike path on the Oregon State University campus.

You ever drive an 18 wheeler through one?

Through it? I don’t know. I don’t think through.

I didn’t even know that was an option.

Okay. Well, the reason  I bring that up is because in 1919, Dwight Eisenhower –

He drove a semi through a covered bridge?

Did they have semis back then?

Well, they had these big military vehicles. This is just after World War I, right? And Dwight was upset because he didn’t get to go fight in the war.

He was too young, or what?

I don’t know – they didn’t send his tank troop overseas. But he’s in Maryland, after the war, right outside of D.C. And this project was conceived of taking a military convoy from one end of the country to the other. And the military at that point was trying to figure out and in some ways, understand, can we move troops across this giant nation? And equipment? And of course, this is the early part of the age of motor vehicles. And so for the military, all these companies that you’ve heard of, you know, like General Motors and Ford — DOD, they had built these big vehicles. So these are larger than normal things. And the idea is you can move equipment and trucks and you know, tanks and supplies long distance for military needs. All kinds of logistics.

Yeah, like I assume most of the factories are in these East Coast towns, or whatever. So you build these tanks or whatever. And you’re saying that let’s get them out to California.

So this was this was like an experiment, or whatever? Like a test that they were trying to undertake?

So wait, was he was in the military at the time?

Yeah, he was sort of a mid level officer on this, I guess Tank Battalion or whatever.

I don’t know. Anyway, he’s excited. He gets to do this. So they leave on July 7, good time of year, right? Not really rainy or anything like that. Good weather, long days. How many days you think it takes them to get across the country? They’re trying to go to San Francisco.

I’ve made that drive – You could do that in three days.

Oh, you could do that in two if you’re really pushing it.

Fucking maniac here. What are you talking about?

But you’ve given us some clues. This is a long, long –

I’m gonna say it’s two weeks.

Okay, so I have an experience. I’ve biked across the country.

Yeah. How long did it take?

We did a longer route than I think what they probably did, because we were circuitous about it. But we probably went about 60 miles a day on average. And I think, you know, there were times where we’d do 80 miles a day, or if you had a good tailwind, you could do over 100. But the whole trip was 100 days. But that was with a lot of days off because we were looking around. So I would think you could do that in like 40 days.

Okay. Okay, that’s all pretty reasonable.

With a bike. So the convoy should have been probably quite a bit faster than that.

And the reason I brought up the covered bridge because one of the problems is they ran into all these places where they couldn’t cross because it was a covered bridge. They had to find ways to get around and it slowed everybody down. And they had to have a scout. They had to have  these guys on motorcycles who had to ride ahead and try to scout and then come back and say, “Okay, I think we can make it if we go right.”

And these are all dirt roads, I’m assuming.

It was all dirt from basically Illinois to Nevada.

So do you got any stats? Like how fast were they averaging?

They were averaging six miles an hour.

Well, yeah. So that’s not very fast jogging speed, you know. It’s a little faster than walking speed.

Yeah, no, it was incredible.

A quick pace of walking, you can get four miles per hour.

Yeah, it was a hazardous journey. I mean, they had about almost 300 people and 21 people didn’t finish the trip because they got hurt or whatever.

So we’ve gone downhill in terms of like our endurance and stamina. Because we’ve talked before about Louis and Clark, right? Those guys didn’t have any fucking trucks. Every one of them made it.

Yeah. We got the stats on that. They were averaging 22 miles per hour, Louis and Clark.

Yeah. So but this made an impression on young Eisenhower. Yeah. Where, gosh, this was tough. This took us a long time. It was logistically difficult. It was dangerous. So you know, if Red Dawn is going down.

Another 80’s reference. Sorry, listeners. Sorry about that.

So, the cool thing here though, is, you know, you’ve got the watershed moment is this cross country journey, but I think there’s a second watershed moment.

This is usual in this series. We’ve got watershed moment take two.

Yeah. So you know, everybody knows Eisenhower as the commander of the allied forces in World War II. So obviously, whatever he did after that trip, he impressed the brass over in the Pentagon.

You’ve got to be careful. You’re gonna upset MacArthur if you don’t explain that he was the Supreme Allied Commander in Europe, not the Pacific.

Yeah, there was a definite ego thing.

They didn’t like each other.

And then he actually got elected president.

Yeah. And maybe that’s a third watershed moment. Getting elected president. But the second watershed moment is he’s over there in Europe. And he goes to Germany, of course. And what does he see there? He sees the autobahn. And he’s like, “Ah, this is way better than what I was thinking of.”

Talk about a highway to hell.

Yeah. Well, and he was drooling over this thing. Like this is what we need in America.

Yeah, that’s amazing to think that the autobahn was built prior to World War II. And it was apparently incredible. And I’ve been on the Autobahn, so yes, yeah. And it is it is pretty fast.

Where have you not been Jason? I mean, really.

There’s a lot of places I’ve never been. I’ve never been in Antarctica.

So um, it’s kind of crazy how fast people go. Oh, yeah. And if you stay in the left lane, you know, Americans have this habit of kind of nonchalantly staying in whatever the fucking lane they’re in. Sorry I’m swearing so much so today.

And if you try to pull that on the autobahn, you’ve got people on your ass with the lights on.

I was in a Saab 900 Turbo. And I was passing a Yugo or something because this is right after Eastern Europe got integrated. And East Germans were driving on the autobahn. But they had these little like tin cars. They had like five guys in it.

They’d go 36 miles per hour.

And so they’re on the autobahn. And I come up at 100 mph behind these cars going about 55. It’s like a Sammy Hagar nightmare. And I’m like going into the left lane. And the next thing I know, some green Mercedes sedan is going 140, and lights are flashing on me. I’m like, “What the hell? I’m going 100.”

Yeah, it’s ridiculous. Well, so we got Eisenhower being shaped up by the lack of progress getting across the U.S. and by the amazing ability to just roll smoothly all over the autobahn like Jason in a Saab. And then, like you said, Asher, he gets elected president. So why don’t you tell us what happens next?

Well, so he’s elected president in late ’52. He takes command of the U.S. as Supreme U.S. commander in 1953. And this idea of having a better highway system, the U.S. had been around a while, they kicked around the idea, but no one had really pulled things together. But Ike has got it, right? He’s gonna push this. He’s motivated. And so it leads it to the passage in 1956 of the Federal Aid Highway Act. And the plan got sold because it was gonna connect all the cities in America that were over 50,000 in population. So politicians everywhere now had a stake in this.

Is that — was that a big city back then? Like Corvallis is over 50,000.

We could have an interstate.

We could have had an interstate.

I don’t think it’s too late, man. Why don’t we go petition for it?

Yeah. Do we have to exhume Eisenhower’s body to make that happen?

I’m sure we can get it. Lots of people want to throw money at –

We can deep fake it. One of the big things was that, you know, it was sold as a reasonable cost. $12 billion. It was sold to be done in a reasonable timeframe. By 1972. And 30 year bonds were sold to pay for it. And it was backed by the federal gas tax. So they didn’t have to spend current dollars. They had to basically, you know, raise money through bonds, and the tax from gasoline sales would pay that back.

And it would take like 20 years or something.

Yeah, I wasn’t going to take too long.

Well, and that’s a brilliant political strategy. You know, it’s like everybody wants it. Just like everybody wants a military base in their district.

And everybody wants a Superfund site in their district.

And the federal government deal was, the state departments of transportation would still kind of run the shows, but 90% of the costs of construction would be paid for by the federal government.  And you had to have standards. So what they did is a standardized things. It had to be a four lane freeway at least, and a freeway, you know, meaning that you’ve got separation of lanes and no at-grade crossings. So this leads to the size. Everything’s got to be pretty darn big. Wide lanes, shoulders, 14 foot clearances when you’re going under underpasses, you know. And so it takes a little longer. Instead of finishing in 1972, it finishes in 1992.

I bet you most of those folks that were planning this thought we’d be flying around in Jetson cars by ’92.

Yeah, it’s true. Why did they think that this was a good investment? We’re gonna be flying around.

I just want to back up for a second. So the federal government was basically paying for all of this, right? So that must have incentivized kind of local states or local communities. You’d be like, yeah, build, build, build. They didn’t have to pay for it.

If you build it, they will come.

Yes. And it led to a lot of overbuilding, of course, too. Because well, the traffic really doesn’t justify a four lane freeway, but you’re paying 90% of it. Let’s go for it. I’ve seen this in action where I was living in rural California. They put in these giant freeways where it’s like, why?

I saw it in Atlanta with these monstrosities. There was one called Spaghetti Junction. That was just like, you know, it seemed like there were about 37 highways crossing each other at this one spot. It kind of became legendary.

There’s some great aerial images of this kind of stuff in various cities. But anyway, it does give you – it ended up being the largest public works program in American history. Ended up costing more than the $12 billion. It ended up costing $129 billion.

446,876 miles for sort of the original build, 16,000 exits and entrances, and about 55,000 bridges and overpasses.

So this is a bigger project more spending than like the dams that we’re undertaking and those public works programs.

Well, I just have in my notes here as the largest public works program.

No, I’m just trying to think of it by scale.

By scale it’s big. They had to figure out – they did all these tests for like, how thick does the concrete need to be? How far apart does the rebar need to be?

But think about how much  even some of the other . . . Like, how much paint did they use to make lane markers or how there’s little reflectors that they put on.

The roadside signs. Everything had to be standardized so that no matter where you were in the country, you understood what was going on.

It’s a good thing that we had a lot of prison labor to make all those those signs on the cheap. That probably kept the cost down a little bit. Well, it wasn’t just the spending. It wasn’t like a one time allocation of spending. Right? You don’t only have to do this once.

No, you’ve gotta keep going.

As everyone knows, there is always highway improvement projects happening everywhere. Life gets better. Everyone’s favorite thing is dealing with those projects that are happening. I think we’re spending now something like, well, between the federal government. . . I know the federal government really spent the money to build out the highways in the first place. When you look at spending for roads now, highways and roads and stuff like that, it’s federal, state and local government. But we spent about what? Like $200 billion a year. Maintenance, maybe building some more stuff. But a lot of it’s really maintenance expenses on that.

That’s more than what the whole build out cost was. Per year. Like we’ve now saddled ourselves with these horrible costs.

And these are inflation adjusted numbers, I just want people understand. So if you were to take that 129 billion, that’d be more like it’d be more like half a trillion today.

But if you think about inflation adjusted, I mean, we spend more than 100% more now than we did in the late 70’s, for example. So, even when you adjust for inflation, we’re spending more money. It’s a lot. And if you think about it in a context of like, where we’re spending money, you know, the big budgets that we have for federal transportation spending. About 41% of it, like in 2021, 41% of like our federal budget for transportation in infrastructure went to highways. And 32% was spent on air travel. So 70 something percent. So if you want to get a sense of context, rail and mass  transit, 19%.

Yeah. And you know, one of the reasons why the cost of maintenance is so high is because compared to the 1950’s, 60’s and 70’s, when the thing was largely built out, the amount of trucking going on now is so much greater. And these heavy trucks really wear on the infrastructure.

Well, and all those covered bridges they smash along the way too.

You’ve gotta keep rebuilding those.

That’s the part I don’t understand. They keep rebuilding these covered bridges. Well, it’s job creation.

Yeah. I appreciate the statistical digging that that you’ve presented here, but I always get drawn to the kind of weird stuff here. I mean, you talked about the, you called it the Federal Aid Highway Act that started this build out. But do you guys know that the actual name of the highway system originally? It had an official name, which was the Dwight D. Eisenhower National System of Interstate and Defense Highways?

That’s an acronym. Geez.

Every once awhile you can go to one of the stop, what do they call them? The rest stops. And there’ll be some placard that explains all this. And Dwight’s, Ike’s, picture is there.

It’s amazing to me because you can think like, Okay, if you’re acting like a hammer, you see everything as a nail, you know, that kind of thing. So it’s like Eisenhower’s this military guy. And he sees everything in the light of national defense. So you know, the whole idea for him for the interstate was we got to make ourselves be able to safely move around all this heavy equipment, missiles and tanks and troops and trucks. And so it’s like, I guess it’s an unused defense system.

You know, well, Cold War too, right? They’re all nervous.

Yeah. And I think it’s something that you brought up, Jason about standardizing things. That required a standardization that would allow for this heavy, heavy machinery to travel on it. You know, high overpasses or bridges or whatever.

Yeah, you could transport missiles standing straight up.

Right in the air. Exactly.

Do you know when we first hit on the idea of looking at the watershed moments and highways, I thought about this, quote/unquote “fact” that I knew, which is that the highway system was built so that like every five miles there would be an ability to land a jet airplane on it.

And that turns out to be a complete falsehood.

Yeah, I think what it actually is is that it wasn’t for jet airplanes, it was UFOs.

Right. Yeah. Total conspiracy theory. But like, we did an episode on susceptibility to conspiracy theories. And I was totally taken in by it. Well, of course, yeah. It’s Dwight Eisenhower. Let’s land planes all over the place. No, but there’s some other cool things, too, that I was not aware of the whole numbering system. Maybe this shows how unobservant I am. But did you guys know that odd numbers are north-south highways, and even numbers are east-west?

Yeah, I actually didn’t know that. You know how you can tell? Because anytime I rode on one of these curves a little bit in another direction, the number changes. You haven’t noticed that?

I have not. I don’t know where have you been driving? Okay, and I got one  little quiz item for you guys. Okay? The widest highway in the world is in the United States. I’ll give you two quizzes. One, how many lanes? Two, what city?

Okay, it’s in a city. Oh my gosh.

Okay, you’ve got LA, Asher. How many lanes, you’ve got to pick a number.

Do you mean on one side or both?

The whole number of lanes in this block.

Okay. I’m gonna go for Dallas. And 14.

Ah, you killing me? See. You were so close to beating, Asher. Neither of you are right on the city. It’s Houston. So close, Jason. You’re in the right state. Texas.

I know. They do big in Texas.

It’s called the Katy highway. And I think it’s like interstate probably plus some access roads on the side. But you needed to up his lane guess. It’s 26 lanes.

No. I gotta get a look at this. I gotta look this up afterwards on Google.

I’m sure there are lots of deer trying to cross that.

Yeah. It’s like a game of Frogger.

I was trying to be reasonable. Never be reasonable.

Well, can we talk about why we’re even talking about this? Like, what are some of the consequences?

Oh, there’s no downside.

Okay, well, you guys know I’ve got the Environmental Studies background. So can I just jump in real quick with a laundry list of environmental consequences.

It’s gonna be just one I think.

You’ve got a minute.

Okay, here we go. So, you know, you’ve got to first mine all that oil and materials for all the infrastructure and the fuel that you need to run around on highways. That of course tears up the land and has all kinds of issues that go with that. Then you need all the materials and the energy for maintaining the highways and plus all of the energy that goes into maintaining this huge private fleet of vehicles.

Okay, let’s let’s talk emissions here for a second. You know, you get the local pollution, the nitrous oxides, ground level ozone. I mean, you know.

Yeah. Good. I mean, I think you picked LA, Asher because of the legendary LA smog, right? I mean, that’s all from driving and highways.

We did a lot of this in a car episode, by the way. We talked about this before. So yeah, we’re repeating ourselves. Sure. Go ahead.

Right. But long term emissions of course, climate change. You know, you’re putting tons of CO2 up into the atmosphere. Let’s talk about water pollution. It’s not something you would necessarily expect but you get all this runoff coming from the highway.

Even the tires. There’s like chemicals in the tires that are screwing up fish.

Well, yeah, you’ve got the pollutants that are  getting in the streams, but you also have the quantity of water. Because when you pave a surface, it becomes impervious and the water just goes flying off into the stream. You get all this erosion.

And it’s a good thing we don’t need more freshwater, you know,

Yeah, no reason to protect and keep that stuff. Right. And then my favorite from the conservation biology side of things is habitat disruptions. I mean, you already mentioned a deer trend. They can be significant barriers. But probably even more important is the way that highways and roads fragment habitat.

It’s a big deal, honestly.

Yeah. It’s mean, this kind of fragmentation and habitat loss, that’s, the leading cause of species extinction.

Well, one of the things that I think about is the dependency now we have on roads because it wasn’t always like that. Prior to the build out of these, this incredible road system ribbons of concrete, we had more energy efficient rail systems in the U.S. Both for long distance and for like this within city kind of trolley ways.

Yeah. We even had rail those connecting towns to each other in Sonoma County, where I used to live in Northern California. It used to be a small gauge rail track that connected Santa Rosa to Sebastopol. It’s now a bike path. But there was rail connecting all of these little towns. Like nine towns.

Marin county, too was like that. Yeah.

And that all disappeared. Bye. Bye.

I know. It’s awful.

Were you allowed to take a hand car out on those lines and take a hand car between towns?

I don’t know. They got rid it before I was there.

I’ve always wanted to try one of those. It seems like such an ancient technology.

So even with bikes, they have a bike that pedals the hand cars now.

Well, you know, this infrastructure has locked us into an oil dependency. We’ve got like 5% of the population, or what do we consume? Somewhere between 20% and 25% of global oil supplies?

Yeah. You mean in the United States?

In the United States, yeah. And we’ve got this built environment now that’s just dependent upon personal automobiles.

Yeah. And I mean, if you think about that dependency, you know, we set out to hear people crowing about the U.S. being energy independent, how much we’re producing. But, you know, we are really dependent upon sources of oil from other parts of the world as well. And we’ve seen what that’s done on a geopolitical basis, right? I mean, you don’t have to look too far in the past to see the connection between geopolitics and oil dependence.

One, I think, you can see some some kind of hidden feedback loops at work too. Because this dependency of being locked into cars and highways and fuel has also led to this separation of our spaces where we live and where we work and where we shop. Because you could get around so easily, you know, just jump in the car. And so now you just drive off to get everything you need. But it’s really caused some problems because a lot of people have to work in the city, but they can’t necessarily afford to live there. So now they’re, whatever, I was gonna say 30 minutes’ drive outside of town, that’s probably optimistic in a lot of places especially with traffic. So people are spending their lives in cars now.

I mean, I love it. I would do that every day if I could.

There’s nothing more fun and gentle than sitting in a long line of traffic while the guy behind you is ramming up your tail and everybody’s shouting at each other. Yeah, relaxing, relaxing.

It’s so relaxing. I love it. Yeah, I think you alluded to this a little bit earlier, Jason, the fact that we built this highway system, and we’ve designed it a certain way to allow for large vehicles to be on it, right? Paved the way, no pun intended, for the trucking industry to become really our primary means of transporting goods.

And think about this. I mean, we have many more passenger vehicles. And we’ve talked about this before, how insane it is that all of us – not all of us, but there are people sitting in a car by themselves stuck in traffic to get someplace.

Or like when you want to go buy 20 pounds of groceries, you got to get there in a 3,000 pound vehicle.

That’s a nice light vehicle. Congratulations.

Yeah, I know. That’s like a Honda Civic.

So we’re all doing that. There are a lot of passenger vehicles out there. But, in fact, most of what is being transported on roads are goods. And, you know, we did this book called, “Our Renewable Future” a few years ago. And we’re sort of looking at how we currently use energy. And we’re looking at the transport sector. And one of the stats that really blew me away is that we transport something like 135 times the amount of weight in goods every year as the total weight of all Americans. And you know how skinny we are?

Yeah, that’s a pretty weird stat. I’m trying to wrap my head around that.

It’s a lot. And the point is, that is a lot. There may be a lot of people on roads, but there is a lot of stuff that we are transporting, and we are dependent upon that stuff.

Well, some of that stuff we’re dependent on.

Some it of, but there’s a lot of essential things that get transported on roads.

Sure. Foods, medicines, but I was just thinking of like

And my big ass screen TV, dude. Come on.

Well, I was thinking about those aisles in the Walmart or the Walgreens or any other wall store that has like the plastic bouncy balls and the rubber dog shit and the fake throw up.

Hey, your non-essential is someone else’s essential.

But what happens when there are diesel shortages? Like there’s an issue with diesel prices or something like that? Like, we’re vulnerable in a way that I think people are maybe able to recognize a little bit more right now because of what we’re dealing with. But that’s a huge vulnerability. Dependence there.

Yeah. You can see, you know, halfway around the world, Russia invades Ukraine, oil and gas prices go up. And yeah, we’re suddenly affected.

Yeah. So the other thing that I think is interesting to bring up about the history of what happened here is that you think about the timing of this. 1956, they start building. This is all going on during the Civil Rights era. And all these Supreme Court laws are passed. The supreme court upholds things that say you can’t have segregation and you can’t keep certain people from living in your area. There were  literally laws that said, “This is the area of town that white people can live, and this is the area of town that black people can live, and they can’t live together.” Those were laws in many places. Those were broken down. Those were destroyed by the Civil Rights Movement and the courts. But smart politicians…

Well, let’s not call them smart.

Sorry about that. Bad, bad word choice.

Because I think I know where you’re going with this.

As soon as you said politician, we knew something was up.

Well, they would basically say, “Let’s use these highway funds that will allow us to build this giant four lane concrete, basically wall barrier.” So we’re talking about, mountain lions and deer having a tough time crossing. Well so do those other people.

Oh, so basically like going to use highways as walls and then have Mexico pay for it?

But what they first did is they used eminent domain today to mostly go through African American neighborhoods, but on the edge of the white neighborhoods so that the African American homes would be wiped out and the road would then keep the rest of that community away from the white community. And this happened in town after town after town. There’s an enormous number of stories. I mean, Birmingham, Alabama, I just give you a specific, they had a racial zoning ordinance where 11th Avenue served at this boundary between the College Hills neighborhood, which was white, and black neighborhoods to the north. And this law was struck down. The College Hills residents were so upset. And they were petitioning to the city commissioners. And they said, “We’ll figure something out.” And so they basically just put the freeway right in that border. And so it precisely mirrors what their zoning had been. Although they had to get rid of that zoning law. So that happened all over the country. And there were. . . Oh, my gosh, just so many, so many homes were destroyed. 475,000 households, and more than a million people were displaced by the building of the highways.

Just by being able to use them.

Yeah, it’s actually have you ever on foot tried to cross an interstate?

No, you’re not supposed to.

I know you’re not supposed to. I’ve done it.

At the time – Well, I’ve done it as an adult and a child actually. And I remember as a child, it had one of those dividers in Middleton we had to get over to. But it’s formidable. I mean, they are wide. And it’s tough. I mean, it’s a true barrier is all I’m trying to say.

Yeah, the highway system, the road system, all the ring roads and the interstates going through major cities. I mean, all this stuff also decimated a lot of farmland. You talk to Jason about people being dispossessed from their homes, and it being used as a tool of segregation, right. But it also decimated farmland, decimated rural communities, or communities that had been maybe on previous roads systems, but then a highway goes through.

Right. Like these little state highways that go through the downtown Main Street.

Isn’t that the movie, “Cars 2?” Wasn’t that about this town? Whatever, one of those. You know, it was about this town that got left behind. And that really hurt a lot of communities. It’s also done something I think that may be more subtle, but just like you’re talking about the uniformity with the highways, around the highways became sort of this uniformity of fast food restaurants, gas stations. And you create the system where there’s like this cookie cutter, ubiquitous, kind of really disgusting, the ugly….

And the uglification of America, you know.

It’s sad to say, but if you picture in your mind a Dunkin Donuts next to an Exxon station, it kind of says Americana in some ways.

I mean, the critic James Howard Kunstler wrote the book “The Geography of Nowhere,” right? Yeah, it’s just awful stuff.

And another thing too I would want to mention is that, and you talked about this a little bit, Rob, is just that, initially there was a kind of like white flight dynamic that happened of people leaving cities and heading to suburbia. Which, obviously, the highway system supported, right? You have a dynamic now, where sort of, I don’t know if it’s a complete and full reversal of that. But there are many people, as we talked about, who can’t afford to live now close to cities where maybe the work is, and they are forced to live in communities further and further and further away. And so this dependence, you know, on the highway system, and on the fuels, it really hits hardest on people who have the least disposable income, right? So you see this dependence on these systems and on the price of oil and gas really, really hitting those hardest who can afford it the least right?

Well, you know, we’ve just run through an enormous number of of consequences, and the kind of things that the build out of the highway system, and how it’s led us into the Crazy Town that we all live in today, but we’re sort of like coming to the party a little late, I’m afraid. Because there was this critic named Lewis Mumford. You guys know him? I’m not talking about The Amazing Mumford the magician.

Was he in Mumford and Sons?

Not talking about him either. What would you call that like the Simon and Garfunkel of new British folk scene or something? I don’t know. Anyway, Lewis Mumford was the social critic who, soon after the Federal Highways Act was passed, he’s got this quote I’m gonna read to you guys. He says, “The most charitable thing to assume about this action is that they hadn’t the faintest notion of what they were doing. Within the next 15 years, they will doubtless find out. By that time, it will be too late to correct all the damage to our cities and our countryside, not least to the efficient organization of industry and transportation that this ill-conceived and preposterously unbalanced program will have wrought.”

Yeah, I mean, Think about it as they thought they were building efficiency, but they weren’t. They were destroying efficiency.

Yeah, I mean, he saw it coming. Right? Unbelievable. And I think he’s getting to kind of a big point about unintended consequences, which maybe a lot of the things that have led us into Crazy Town that we’ve been discussing in this season on watershed moments have these unintended consequences. But in the early stages of this federal highway program, and this build out of roads in America, probably most people felt like this great win-win where you’ve got the politician saying, “Okay, money for my district,” and you’ve got local people saying, “Oh, build out and modernization.”

I mean, think about the vision. Let’s connect every community that’s 50,000 people or more. That sounds wonderful.

That’s like Facebook. Let’s just connect people. What could go wrong?

Yeah. I mean, almost nobody could see these systemic problems coming up. And I really think we need to emphasize one of these, which is kind of the most important and the scariest unintended consequence. And you’ve been kind of bringing it up a little bit here and there, both of you guys. It’s the extent to which we are locked into, essentially an unworkable infrastructure here in the United States.

I used to love that, you know, we went to Venezuela, asking them to send us more oil recently, and Saudi Arabia, begging them to turn on the taps, but they’re not so happy with us, because  we’ve been kind of getting on their case for killing a journalist. And so it’s just absurd, isn’t it? When the price of oil and gas goes up and we freak out and just start asking  the folks that we’ve presumably been upset about –

I mean, the official response is do anything you can to bring the prices back down. I mean, you mentioned begging our so called allies to open the taps. But we’ve also seen states putting a hiatus on the gasoline tax. We’ve seen the Biden administration talk about opening up the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, just so you can flood some supply into the market. You’ve got people rallying around the ideas of getting fracking and tar sands development going again, turning Alberta, Canada back into a petro state.

I mean, they already are and it’s not like that shut down. It’s just that people assume you can just always do more. We can always just like drill more, always frack more, and have no idea what it takes. It’s like a water tap you can turn on.

That’s like the proof of how locked in we are. Here’s a moment where you can make a pivot to renewable energy or try something different. But no, we’re just going to keep the prices low. Asher, I feel like there’s steam coming off of your head. I feel like you have some anger around this issue.

I have anger about it. I  also just have a lot of consternation, because I’m pissed. And if you’ve seen . . . You could go back, people do this all the time. You know, they do these retrospectives on presidents, going back to Nixon, talking about getting off of our dependence on fossil fuels. Every single fucking president, Democrat, Republican doesn’t matter. They all talk about the need to do that.

Retro Trump did not talk about the need to do that.

That’s true. Let’s give him credit. Clean, beautiful coal. That is true. I guess the one thing you could say is at least he’s not a hypocrite now. He was straight about it. But you’ve had people for decades and decades and decades and decades recognize that this is a vulnerability of ours. Right? And we’re locked in. And frankly, there isn’t a simple solution. Right? We’re in a situation right now, because of the investments we made, not least of which is this highway system, right? And all the changes that end up creating in terms of our built environment, where people live, how we provision ourselves with food and other goods that we need. We built this fucking system that that’s cost us trillions and trillions of dollars. Who knows how many hydrocarbons burned and other resources, displacing people, displacing nature, all this shit, right? And we are stuck in a place now where the things that we would need to do to transition ourselves away from that is a fundamental systemic structural infrastructural transformation, right? And to do something like that, at this day and age, which we know we need to do for a number of reasons. Climate being not the least of them. But so is the fact that we’re dependent upon fossil fuels. And anything that happens in the market, a war that happens that involves a Petro state or the simple fact that you’re scraping the bottom of the barrel with  the cheap and easy stuff. So anything that we do that’s really substantive that’s going to get to the heart of that would require a transformation of all of these things, right? It’s just not about suddenly driving a fucking EV car on the highway. Where do you think the material comes from to –

Hey, we can make roads out of solar panels.

Okay, we talked about that. All the stuff that goes into these cars, the plastic and the steel and everything. I mean, we’ve looked and done this analysis. It’s all dependent upon these resources. But we’re now in a situation where we’re going to say, “Okay, we kind of get off this shit, right?” We don’t have a ton of time to do it because of climate. We don’t have a time ton of time to do it because of depletion. And if we did it substantively, it will require sacrifice, dramatic change, or really impact people. And guess what? That ain’t gonna fly.

Well, the kicker is that I agree with you, we need to be on a massive program of shared sacrifice and devotion to that transformation. But you can see how psychologically invested the public is in the status quo and in the burning of gasoline.

But they’re not just psychologically invested, they are materially invested. You can’t just say to people, especially people who are living at the margins, right? More and more Americans are living at the margins. To save them, guess what? Tighten your belt, we’re going to basically let prices go up, or whatever we’re going to do, we’re going to make these kinds of sacrifices. It’s gonna hit those people really hard.

Yeah. Well, I mean, think about it. It was at the International Energy Agency, after prices started going up, when Russia invaded Ukraine, they came up with a 10 point plan which is sort of loaded with what you think of as fairly straightforward. Okay, yeah, that’s a good way to use less gas. So they have things like reduce highway speed limits, work from home, go car free on Sundays. And you know, that’s three of the 10. But there’s more like that. And I can think of some people I know who would be like, you know, they’re telling me to go car free on Sundays, I’m going to drive twice as far just to spite them.

We couldn’t even get consensus on wearing masks or getting vaccinated, right? To think that we’re going to get consensus on, “On this day, you can’t drive your car,” or whatever it is. And that’s even if people can afford to do some of this stuff. And this is why when you hear proposals, Biden administration putting out proposals to address climate change, you know. When it comes to the transportation system, it’s all about electric vehicle charging stations. Because we can’t imagine, and we can’t actually make an investment in a system that’s completely different.

We need a system that does not require this high amount of fossil fuel inputs at every stage of production, extraction, reformation, distribution, storage, processing, consumption, disposal.

How many nouns can you put in a row here?

Every single frickin’ step of almost everything? We touch all 835 pounds of stuff per person, or 835 times?

That’s for a one pound person.

I weigh myself and then multiply eight. That’s how much stuff is being – all of it is touched by fossil fuels. So if you say, the price of fossil fuels go up, just multiply that price of that one input across all the steps in the economy, which are completely dependent upon it. So we need to do something different. Something maybe the opposite.

Let’s see if we can fuel things on righteous anger and frustration. Hey, in our ongoing shameless attempt to get more reviews out on iTunes, this is a part where we share a particularly good review. You guys want to hear it?

Okay. This is from Chaka Harta from about a year ago. That’s a great name. Chaka Harta says, “Smart topical discussion with information about staying sane in our current era. Science, politics, psychology, business, government, and a healthy amount of irreverent humor throughout. Most importantly, the hosts seem to really know their stuff from working in the trenches on these issues for years.”

She didn’t cover aliens.

That’s true.  We did have aliens in the list of topics. But I like the whole idea of working in the trenches. I’ve never seen either of you in a trench.

Well, Jason’s always wearing mud boots.

I do have a lot of mud boots and I get out in the field and it’s muddy. I dug a trench when I was in high school one time. I had a temporary job.

I think you send other people into the trenches when necessary. You’re like one of these evil congressional guys.

Yeah, I’m not gonna go fight. Well, that’s really sweet, though. Thank you. I’m glad somebody likes our podcast.

Yes, thank you, Chaka Harta, for that wonderful review. And please, if you like this show, get anything out of it, maybe a laugh here and there. Go over to iTunes, or wherever you get your podcasts and drop us a review. It helps other people find it.

Every decision I’ve ever made in my entire life has been wrong. My life is the complete opposite of everything I want it to be.

If every instinct you have is wrong, then the opposite would have to be right.

Okay, so when we’re talking about doing the opposite of the National Highway Act, right? The highway system that we built. You know, I immediately think of what we would do at sort of federal policy. At the highest levels, right? What would we do there? And dithering around and the way that we are with trying to like transition our highway system or transportation system is not anywhere near enough. So, here some bold ideas. People are begging the fossil fuel companies to drill more now. And they don’t want to do it in the United States after having spent a decade fracking away with all the consequences of that.

And losing money. And now they’re making money because oil prices have gone up and you can’t convince them to drill. So fuck those guys. Let’s nationalize the industry. I mean, I know that sounds crazy, but we bailed out the auto industry 12 years ago, whatever it was, you know, 13 years ago. And stop it. Let’s take control. This is not an issue that can be solved by the whim of the market.

And I know the biggest oil companies in the world are nationalized already. So what is the advantage of nationalizing?

Because we can direct. We can actually say, these are the goals. Another goal for these companies is to make money. So our goal could be, let’s use the energy that we have available to us. If we have to use fossil fuels, which we acknowledge we do. We cannot go cold turkey overnight. Let’s use them to support a transition that’s a just transition, a sustainable transition to something else.

So you’re making corporate decisions. Instead of based upon how do we make as much profit, you’re saying, this is a key input to the industrial civilization. And we need to wean ourselves off it steadily, progressively, as quickly as we can,

Invest these resources where they need to go.

Yeah, for a common good

And along those lines, you know, again, trying to think what would we do that was the opposite? We might have to think about rationing energy consumption.

Right, because if you’re ratcheting down fossil fuel production, then you have to ratchet down demand or prices are gonna spike and then the poorest won’t have any access to it.

Plus climate is pushing this too. We should have had a ration in place quite a long time ago.

And I don’t know if we talked about tradable energy quotas on this podcast before, but tradable energy quotas is something that we at PCI have written about and spoken about. You know, we can put that in the show notes for folks. So that’s one way of trying to do it that is more equitable. But a way of basically saying we have to ration and limit, but be very mindful.

Yeah, in season two we had a whole episode on rationing, which was our least popular episode of all time.

Nobody wants to hear it.

Shocker. Yeah. Well, hell Jeff Bezos is going out into space and harvesting the moon because he can’t stand the thought of rationing.

Well, one of the things that you got to think about in doing the opposite is what the highway system undid, which as you top the program off today, Jason talked about how the rail system got decimated. And so, one of the things we also need to do at the probably higher levels of government federal state is to revive these other transportation networks, rail canals and even . . .

Yeah, I mean they’re great. I love rickshaws.

Well, I was gonna say, you can’t haul nearly as much cargo, but I love the bike infrastructure too. And something I’ve actually noticed a lot around Portland lately, the city where I live, is that it’s like we hold the roads sacred. Keep the road open and free flowing, but the bike pas thare getting taken over and they’re littered and they’re sort of like falling into disrepair and the train station is a mess. These should be the parts of the infrastructure that we emphasize. And let’s start de-emphasizing the roads and the cars. And in fact, you mentioned a couple of seconds ago, Asher, but like, bailing out car companies. Next time they’re facing bankruptcy, can we just let them slide off into the sunset and call it quits?

So where are you calling for is, let’s de-beautify the roads? Let’s throw our waste in the road but not in the bike lanes.

Just think about if accidentally there was a 40 foot barrier that just appeared in the middle of the highway? Would that be so bad?

Just don’t do it on a foggy day on me.

Like I come to this idea that we have 835 times our body weight in stuff moving around. And a lot of that is because we’ve hyper specialized production of something in one location of the world. And we’ve had episodes on this and how much everything gets on shipping containers and transported around the world. And if you want to reduce the transportation intensity, and remove the need for all this infrastructure, then you’ve got to regionalize your production system and make it geared towards local consumption. An example around here, like we used to have a walnut industry in the Willamette Valley. We grew commercial walnuts. But once I-5 corridor gets put in, suddenly, it’s a little bit cheaper to grow walnuts in California. And so they out compete the walnuts from Oregon, and our Walnut industry disappears. But if you kind of had sort of, say trade barriers in the sense of, no, it’s expensive to get anything between here and California because there’s that 40 foot barrier along I-5. Then suddenly, it’s like you’re really focusing on diversifying each region for the array of goods and services that are needed in that region. And so it’s not like you don’t need transportation, but the scale of transportation required then gets downgraded quite a bit. And it’s not trying to go as far, it’s not trying to go through centralized systems for ultra high tech packaging and processing. But then if you look at how much energy is used, not just to produce and distribute, but also to get the final kind of mile, where it’s getting into the home of people, the household level. People are driving forever just to go to the big box stores. Those have to disappear too. And if you’ve ever been in one of these, like your old European cities, where there’s a grocery store on every corner, you understand that it’s the ability to walk outside, go down the street a little ways and buy what you need. And that is that’s such an incredible thing to have.

So dealing with that that goes hand in hand with with ideally re-localizing where that stuff came from in the first place, right?

Right. You’re cutting out at all these different ends then and so there’s a book actually, “Retrosuburbia” by David Holmgren. It’s a very interesting look at how you would take our current built environment and retrofit it. Of course, most of this is illegal to do like we can’t have retail outlets at the corner of a suburban house right now.

The problem is we imagine it like a Walmart is going to drop off the corner as opposed to what you’re talking about. Some, you know, Mom and Pop kind of shop.

Yeah, somebody takes the initiative and has a corner grocery on the side of their house.

And there are actually organizations like the Sustainable Economies Law Center, that work at some of these laws, you know, ordinances and things that are on the books that disincentivize people basically either having their own home production of food or whatever that they could sell, or other ways of provisioning.

Yeah, break down all the legal barriers to local livelihoods, provisioning, distribution, sales, etc., and mix it all up again. Like it used to be in the old days.

Yeah. And I think it’s really key what you said, which is that the whole idea of Retrosuburbia. We have to recognize that there’s a lot of built infrastructure that’s going to remain in a sense what it is, right? And so we have to be very creative in making the most of what we do have.

And I want to take this down t almost like a very individualized level or maybe apply for the household. But one of the things that I think you can really do is sort of try to immunize yourself from being so reliant on this infrastructure and this fossil fuel. And I know we’ve talked about, you probably have to have a certain amount of privilege or cushion to be able to do that because some people are locked into these really tough situations. So maybe this isn’t applicable all over the place. But this has been on my mind a lot because of something that happened to me recently with the car that I use in order to be able to get down and hang out with you guys here in Corvallis and record this podcast. So I have this hybrid car, right? It gets about 50 miles of distance on the electric engine. And when the batteries run out of juice, it switches over to the gas engine. So you know, I’m one of these, like, holier than thou hybrid drivers, right? And this valve on the car broke. And so what that caused was an overheating anytime the gas engine was in use. So basically, it became unsafe to drive the car in gas mode. However, the show must go on. So I had to shut up. I had to get down here.

No, I wish. I did take the train one time, which was fun. But what I took to doing was, I would drive the car in electric mode, stop halfway in, recharge it and then drive the other half. Now this car does not have a fast charge. So basically, what this meant was my trip went from being around an hour and a half in time length to being five and a half hours. And it also meant that I drove on much slower roads because I could get farther per electric charge. So I wasn’t on the interstate. And I noticed some real changes. Like one, I enjoyed the slowing of it because I don’t know, it’s just more scenery, Oregon’s beautiful, I was along the Wallenda river.

You were listening to life is a highway.

You walked on the highway.

Yeah, But also, I was I guess meditating on it a lot. The slowing down was okay. The only reason it sucks is because everybody else is able to go faster and I’m sort of the only one who’s taking this extra time.

I think if we all kind of had it a little bit slower and had a little bit more connection with the landscapes that were traversing, you would you would have an improved quality of life. And the time that I came down here by train and bike, that was even more fun. And it actually took me less time than the damn car.

Well look, I know you’re trying to bring it down to the personal level, I’m going to bring it even more personal level which is, I think if we see the enormity of this issue that we’re facing, there’s only one recourse. Just stop moving.

Well that’s the ultimate slowing down,

You mean like…  You’re not talking about moving from your house. You’re talking about just staying in one place.

Don’t move please. Just don’t move. That’s brilliant. Be like a tree.

If tree can do it, so can we.

What if I’m hungry?

Be a sit-and-wait predator. Be like a snake.

Thanks for listening. We just gave you a whole bunch of do the opposite ideas so you can take action in your life and community. If that’s too much at this time in your life, do something real simple. Give us a five star rating on Spotify or any other podcast app and hit the share button to let your friends know about Crazy Town.

Today’s sponsor is KHWY, the all-highway station. Nothing but songs about the open road, great car sex, being stuck in traffic, drive and drug crash and tow trucks, speedways, jacked up trucks, low riders and for you, they might be giants eco-freak types, even electric cars. KHWY, Rockin’ the American Road since 1956.

Oh, baby this town rips the bones from your back. It’s a death trap, it’s a suicide rap. We gotta get out while we’re young . ‘Cause tramps like us…

Jason Bradford and Rob Dietz

Baby, we were born to run.

Asher became the Executive Director of Post Carbon Institute in October 2008, after having served as the manager of our former Relocalization Network program. He’s worked in the nonprofit sector since 1996 in various capacities. Prior to joining Post Carbon Institute, Asher founded Climate Changers, an organization that inspires people to reduce their impact on...

Resilience is a program of Post Carbon Institute, a nonprofit organization dedicated to helping the world transition away from fossil fuels and build sustainable, resilient communities.